Actions

Work Header

Speak Easy

Summary:

"Carraway." There came a brief pause as Jay Gatsby's eyes raked over my face, inspecting my jawline and cheekbones with a critical air. Comparing. I felt more naked than ever before in my life, a part of me convinced that he would notice something amiss through my flannel suit. Naturally, he only asked, "Any relation to Daisy Fay? I heard mention of that name from her a time or two."

Notes:

Hello and welcome to my "The Great Gatsby is finally in the public domain!" celebration fic. It's ours now, Fitzy. We can put our queer little hands all over it.

While this fic significantly alters the plot, mixes up the flashbacks, adjusts the timeline, and changes rather a lot just generally, I've treated what's coming with the utmost sincerity. I love this novel with my whole heart; I can only hope my fic does it at least a little bit of justice. Thank you for joining me here <3

3/31/2022: I've fixed a few typos and edited the first chapter so that it flows better style-wise with the rest of the fic :)

Chapter 1

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

When it came time to marry Tom Buchanan, they found me in the stuffy back room of the church while bells rang merrily out over the rooftops in welcome. I was hyperventilating and clawing ineffectually at the zipper of my dress. A bridesmaid (Jordan, the only one I'd insisted on having, and therefore also the only one who hadn't been appointed to the wedding party by Tom) reached for me in a rare moment of emotional insight and unzipped it. One quick tug wrenched it open to the small of my back and I collapsed to the floor beside an older, abandoned altar, sobbing and overcome by a haunting loneliness as I clutched the gaping fabric to my chest. I vividly recall being struck by the sight of a bottle of communion wine nestled into the shadows of the altar: the only object in the room other than ourselves that was not covered in a layer of dust.

I left the church through a side door; I cannot imagine I would have escaped unmolested out the front. I don't know who spoke to Tom, or what they told him, or the words that were used to disperse the large crowd which had gathered to see us marry. I asked Jordan to run in and tell them all that Daisy had changed her mind, but to this day I haven't bothered asking if she actually did it. She may have had more decorum.

This was the rumored start to my illness, I heard later. I couldn't bring myself to care.

I slipped through the white ribboned hedges in the last pair of high-heeled shoes I would ever wear, the morning sun throwing my shadow westward across the lawn.

That night, I lifted a mostly empty bottle of communion wine in a toast to myself, to Tom’s continued absence, and to the bright sparkling future I felt sure I could now attain.


It had come to me over tea one morning, and it came fully formed. I was stirring sugar into my teacup—one eye on the newspaper at my elbow, some corner of my mind concerned with an issue we were having with the wedding caterer—and it dropped in from the sky, taking root as though it had always been there.

I'm a man.

It was an almost absent realization, the culmination of details collecting unnoticed until something small and unidentifiably innocuous tipped the scales, but it was one that—once realized—became a thought I turned over in my mind at nearly every waking moment, prodding it for weaknesses, insecurities. Faults.

There were none.

And so, four months after what would have been my wedding day, and two years after I first brought Jay Gatsby home, I entered a hospital with an overnight bag and several kinds of courage, leaving again a short time later with a flat, tender chest and the name Nick clenched victoriously between my teeth.

Notes:

The events of Gatsby are set during the summer of 1922. Synthetic hormones were first manufactured in 1920, and one of the first documented gender-affirming surgeries performed in the United States was in 1917, a hysterectomy/gonadectomy for Dr. Alan L. Hart.

I'm handling the existence of gender-affirming surgeries in this fic as though they happened regularly in the '20s, if not frequently. I simply find it impossible to believe that no surgeons existed who—if not sympathetic towards the difficulties of trans people—weren't willing to be bribed into performing "unnecessary" double mastectomies.