Chapter Text
When they got into the prom Tweek felt very self-cautious as it seemed everyone they walked by had their eyes glued to him. He had expected that though. The minute he agreed to let Kenny, Bebe and Nichole dress him up like a ken doll- or well Barbie tonight- he knew what he was signing himself up for but he hadn’t quite expected this. He had been expecting the stares of course- but he had been expecting them to be in confusion and maybe even disgust at the blonde boy in a dress but instead jaws were dropping and both girls and their boyfriends were hyping him up much to his embarrassment.
He stayed close behind his friends as they made it into the hall which was decorated in golden banners and balloons, Tweek had no clue what the theme was but if he had to guess it would most likely be something to do with the colour gold. There was so many people in the room and the tables which had been set up at the side of the room was full of people talking and taking selfies and drinking the definitely not already spiked punch.
Craig sat with Clyde much to his regret as what seemed like the whole cheer squad sat perched around them. Clyde of course was waiting on Bebe as were most of the girls before they could start taking pictures where as Craig was just feeling miserable knowing the only reason he was here tonight was because his parents would ask too many questions if he didn’t. He planned on just sucking it up for a few hours and walking home trying to forget about prom.
“Don’t you think Craig?” Some girl he didn’t know said a shy smile on her face.
“Huh?” He said confused
“Its really pretty in here” She said “The prom committee done so good”
“Yeah” Craig nodded not really interested in engaging with the girl
“Bebe just text they just got here” Clyde turned to his friend
“Who is she with?” Craig asked
“Oh uh- Nichole I think” Clyde shrugged
“Ah” Craig said uninterested.
“Your prom date not coming?” Annie asked- this girl he unfortunately did know and would be a lot harder to just shrug off.
“Nope” Craig said coldly
“Shame, we could have gone if your friend didn’t insist on being such a kill joy” Annie touched his hair softly from the seat beside him and Craig leaned back away from her not wanting her to get any sort of indication that there was even a chance he was interested in her.
“Oh dont be like that” She giggled “You know you love it when I touch you”
“I really don’t” Craig swatted her hand rolling his eyes
“You wernt saying that when-“
“Annie can you fuck off?” Craig asked in as firm yet non-threatening voice. Last thing he needed was to be kicked out for starting fights with Annie.
“Why are you always like this, just relax a little-“
“Annie-“
The blonde girl in the tight shimmery pink dress stood and sat herself directing into his lap.
“Annie what the fuck, have you never heard the word no before” Craig tried to push her from his lap but she clung on around his neck as the other girls giggled making Craig sigh accepting his fate.
“Oh don’t be mad at me, you know you still love me” Annie whispered
“Still? I never loved you” Craig took his turn to laugh
“You’re just in denial, we both know im the best you have ever had and ever will have” Annie stroked his cheek softly “Lets just get wasted and go back to your place, ill let you fuck me-“
“As awful as that sounds and really Annie I must emphasis that, it sounds truly awful, I do in fact have plans”
“With who?” Annie asked
“My hand and porn hub, its better than you anyway” Craig said and Clyde catching in on the convocation let out a loud belly laugh making Craig smile.
“Hey guys!” Bebe pushed her way into the group “Im here!”
“Bebe!” The girls rushed to her gushing over her dress and shoes and whatever else.
“Hey girls” Kenny mocked her as he sat beside Clyde and Craig and Annie who was not letting go.
“Oh and Annie, nice to see you’re still as desperate as ever” Kenny sniggered
“Oh says you” Annie scowled
“I would get out of Craigs lap if I were you though his prom date is about to arrive”. Kenny said smugly relishing in both the anger and distain on her face as well as the obvious confusion on Craigs.
“T-Tweek is here?” Craig asked
“Yeah, he’s just getting us a drink” Kenny smiled “I cannot wait to see your face”
“My face?” Craig now even more confused raised an eyebrow “Kenny what have you been smoking?”
“Oh nothing, you will se- oh here he is” Kenny gasped in excitement as Tweek appeared behind the group of girls who all gasped on seeing him.
“Tweek?” Craigs mouth hung open a little
“Hey” Tweek said nervously handing a drink to Kenny and holding onto the other himself as he sat with the boys.
“What are you wearing?” Clyde asked “You look like a chick”
“That’s the idea” Kenny chuckled
“Why?” Craig asked
“You look ridiculous” Annie frowned as she glared at the boy in a nicer dress than she was.
“So do you” Kenny cut in “And if you don’t mind, leave”
“Craig doesn’t want me to” Annie snipped back
“I don’t know why you think that, I want nothing more than for you to leave” Craig rolled his eyes
“Fine, whatever gaybos” Annie scoffed as she slouched down beside the girls.
“You look good” Craig cleared his throat nervously
“Thanks” Tweek said as he felt his cheeks go warm. Craig looked so good in a suit and the memory of the kiss replayed in his head. He wanted nothing more now than to kiss him again and again but knew he would have to wait for it
The night seemed to drag on and Tweek could feel Craigs eyes linger on him wherever he was in the room. Whenever they were around each other things were tense to say the least and neither had to courage to start up a convocation without the company of their friends. Every girl was taking photos and both Tweek and Craig could feel themselves forcing smiles much like they had been the whole night.
“Its slow dance time now, ladies and gentlemen, grab your partners and get on down to the dance floor-“Tweek wasn’t quiet sure what the DJ was saying as he made his way against the group of teenagers where he decided to sit this one out alone at a table and probably just scroll on his phone.
The slow music began to play and Tweek looked up to see his friends all dancing together and he felt his heart swell with happiness for them. That was when he felt it again. Craigs eyes lingering on him and he turned to see him sitting at another table alone.
He swallowed his pride and gathered the courage to go over and as he watched him approach Craig felt his palms get sweaty and his heart begin to race. The night had been nothing like he had been planning on- hell he was planning on leaving an hour ago but yet he was still here- for him.
“Hey” Tweek said coyly sitting across from Craig. The tension was thick and their nerves high as Craig felt his dry mouth struggle to talk.
“Um- How are you?” Craig asked
“Im fine… how are you?” Tweek toyed with his fingers anxiously feeling his heart flutter when he looked up at Craig.
“I’m okay… I didn’t expect you to come” Craig admitted
“Me neither… but Kenny convinced me” Tweek shrugged “I uh… I told him about what happened”
“Oh god” Craig cringed “Im surprised he hasn’t made fun of me yet”.
“I’m really sorry I freaked out the way I did-“
“No Tweek, im the one who is really sorry, I should never have just kissed you that was so creepy and weird of me, you’re my best friend and I-“
“Craig shit up. I wanted you to kiss me, hell, I’ve been wanting you to kiss me since we were 13 but I panicked and I regret it now because Kenny made me realised I had no reason to be scared” Tweek sighed looking up into Craigs eyes which seemed to see into the depths of his soul.
“Scared? Of me?” Craig asked swallowing the lump in his throat
“No I… the way all your relationships go, hell Craig you don’t have a great track record and I was scared if I kiss you back I would fall even more in love with you and then in 2 weeks I would end up like all your other ex’s and I didn’t want to lose our friendship, I didn’t want to lose you” Tweek chewed the inside of his lip. It was hard for him to explain his emotions and hell he knew Craig found it even harder.
“But you’re nothing like them. I’ve been in love with you since I knew what that meant, you’re everything ive ever wanted and until recently I guess I couldn’t admit that” Craig admitted holding his own hand under the table toying with his fingers nervously.
“Do… Do you want to dance with me?” Tweek asked
“I don’t think I know how to” Craig chuckled
“Me neither” Tweek shrugged “Come” Tweek stood reaching a hand out for Craig and he led him to the edge of the dance floor hands usure of where to go as they resigned to Tweek wrapped his arms around Craigs neck and Craigs arms around Tweeks waist.
“I feel like a chick” Tweek smirked
“You look like one too” Craig reminded him “A really pretty one”
“Do I look prettier as a girl or a guy?” Tweek asked
“Um…” Craig gulped “A guy I suppose but that’s just the gay speaking”.
“I wonder if Bebe had given me those heels if I would be taller than you?” Tweek squinted
“Of course you would be, were like basically the same height already” Craig reminded him
“Is that your type?” Tweek asked “Tall, skinny guys?”
“Nah, just you” Craig grinned making Tweeks cheeks flush a warmer pink.
“Tweek” Kenny hissed giving him a thumbs up making them both chuckle.
“You wanna get out of here?” Craig asked
“And go where?”
“My place?”
“Yeah, okay” Tweek nodded following Craig out of the gym just as the song ended blending in the crowd as they escaped feeling the cool air outside hit their burning skin.
“Fuck its cold” Tweek hissed as he quickly jumped into Craigs car passenger seat.
“I’ll put the heat on” Craig said as they sat for a moment in comfortable silence. It was so dark and quiet outside, the faint noise of the prom inside could just be heard and the whistle of the wind battering the car on the cold summer night.
“I’m sorry I never text, I was scared you never wanted to see me” Craig said finally
“I get that… I should have text. It wasn’t fair to leave you worried” Tweek sighed
“Im just happy things have worked out” Craig smiled “Im just… really, really happy”
“Me too” Tweek blushed biting at his bottom lip. The soft light inside the car made it feel even warmer as Tweek waited for Craig to drive them back to his home.
The whole town seemed so silent and Tweek looked out the window listening to the fuzzy radio playing until he parked up into the drive way.
“Hey” Craig said opening the door. Trisha lay on the couch watching Twilight ignoring her brother and Tweek as they came in. “Where’s mom and dad?”
Trisha shrugged making her brother roll his eyes “Thanks” Craig mumbled as he walked by her going up to his bedroom, Tweek following close behind clicking the door shut behind him as he turned and Craig pressed him back up against the closed door.
“Hey” Tweek gulped nervously as Craigs body pressed against him.
“Can I kiss you?” Craig asked. His chest heaved and his heart pounding as he looked into Tweek’s bright eyes. Now he was this close to him Craig noticed the makeup more. The black mascara which was smudging at the side of his eyes and the slightly crumbling concealer.
“Shut up” Tweek mumbled as he pulled Craigs face into his own feeling his lips move against his own. There was no slowing down. The heat and tension between them was hot and intense and they could both feel it radiating through them.
“Sit on the bed” Tweek panted and Craig nodded stepping back and sitting on the edge of his bed. Tweek dropped to his knees between Craigs open legs the dress beginning to annoy him as it hard for him to move his legs.
“Are you sure?” Craig asked.
“Ive been dreaming of this for years, god-“Tweek groaned as he unzipped Craigs pant zipper, Craig lifting his hips as Tweek tugged his pants and underwear down in one motion. Tweek could feel his mouth salivate at the hard throbbing erection in front of him.
“You’re so hard” Tweek gasped as his hands ran up Craigs thighs.
“You’re so beautiful” Craig groaned, his whole body burning with lust as Tweek couldn’t take his eyes off the cock in front of him. Craig thought maybe he was dreaming and Tweek thought the same thing as ever fantasy he had ever had suddenly was right Infront of him and he didn’t know what to do.
He sunk his lips into the soft flesh of Craigs thigh kissing into the skin grazing his teeth over it lightly making Craig gasp as the intense suction from his mouth moved up his thigh into the inside of his leg. Tweeks head between his legs as his mouth moved from his leg over to his balls cupping them in his hand before sucking on them. He wasn’t sure if that was something Craig would like but the long muffled groan coming from the boy above him told him it was in fact something he enjoyed.
He focused there for a while enjoying teasing the dark-haired boy. His legs were quivering either side of him and Tweek knew that for someone with virtually no experience this was a very good sign. He ran his hands over Craigs shaking legs before lifting his leg to look up at the boy who was looking down at him with a look of almost disbelief. His face was flushed and cheeks rosy, red as his chest heaved and his mouth dry.
Neither exchanged any words as Tweek wrapped a hand around Craigs cock which had been hard when he had taken off his pants but now it was throbbing and felt almost solid in Tweeks hand from the pent up frustration begging to be realised. Just the feeling of Tweeks soft hands on his dick made Craig whimper as he tried to focus on just breathing through the timid slow strokes Tweek was inflicting on him.
Tweek didn’t know exactly what to do, Craig had foreskin where he had not but that seemed to be to his advantage. He kissed the tip pulling back the foreskin a little seeing the glistening head poking out leaking precum.
The blonde wasn’t sure how good this was going to be but he knew Craig would tell him if he hurt him so with a surge of courage he wrapped his lips around the cock Infront of him sucking just around the top working up the courage he needed to get more of the shaft into his mouth.
Craig gasped covering his mouth with his hand. He had received head before- hell he had probably had more head than he had hot food- but most the time it was shit and he would think about something else just to get to the end but right now he was trying to think of something else to stop him from busting in Tweeks mouth when he had just started.
Craig thought for sure Tweek must have lied to him about being a virgin and having never gone this far with anyone because there was no other way the blonde boy could be so good at sucking cock.
“Oh god” Craig panted closing his eyes and grabbing the sheets of the bed feeling them bunch around his knuckles as his grip tightened. Prying his eyes open he grunted looking at the boy chocking down more of his length into his mouth. Craig supposed from a certain angle Tweek could be mistaken for a girl. The way his hair was styled and the dress slipping from his shoulders and regardless of the makeup Tweek had a rather soft pretty face.
It was just then Craig moaned unable to stop himself and he thought maybe that was what he had been missing all this time. Sure girl were pretty and hell- many of them could suck his dick perfectly fine but the one thing they didn’t have was a cock which Craig could see Tweek stroking with one hand with his other was wrapped around his cock along with his mouth.
“Oh Tweek I cant-“ Craig moaned “I need to come-please-please”
Tweek removed his mouth drool and precum dripping from his lips and he continued to stroke both his own and Craigs cock “Come for me” Tweek gasped as his heart raced in his chest looking up to Craig who was seeing stars struggling to breath as his body went limp before Tweek could wrap his lips around his cock again gasping as spurts of cum spilled from Craigs cock onto Tweeks face and hair and down his chest.
“Oh god” Tweek said in shock freezing up.
“Im so sorry” Craig gulped scrambling to get his tissues to clean the mess from Tweek however Tweek only chuckled as Craig wiped his cheek “Huh?” Craig said confused before Tweek wiped his finger across his chest gathering the cum and wiping it into his tongue sucking it from his finger.
“Tweek, ew” Craig frowned as he kept wiping his face.
“God that might be the hottest thing ive ever seen” Tweek admitted as Craig cleaned the dripping semen from his eyebrow.
“Ditto” Craig grinned
“I need a shower” Tweek said as he felt the semen in his hair.
“What about-“
“We can finish this later, okay?” Tweek smirked
“Cool” Craig nodded “Well um… you know where the bathroom is”
“Things are different aren’t they” Tweek said
“Yeah… it feels new” Craig shrugged “Like don’t know you”
“Ditto” Tweek smiled taking his turn to use it back on him “I guess this is all new”.
“I guess we have a lot to learn about each other” Craig said
“Well… ill be back soon” Tweek said slipping out the bedroom and across the hall to the bathroom leaving Craig alone with his thoughts in his bedroom. There was no doubt in his mind that was possibly one of the best orgasms he had ever had in his whole life. The way Tweek had looked with his cock stuffed in his mouth was engrained in his memory and just the thought made his dick twitch a little.
He lay on his bed covering his face with his pillow as he gathered some form of composure calming himself until the thought crossed his mind. ‘WHAT DID TWEEK MEAN WE CAN FINISH THIS LATER?’
What was Tweek expecting? Craig to give him head? Sure, he could try, he couldn’t say he had ever done it before or that it would be any good but he could try his best. But what If he was expecting… more?
Was Tweek expecting Craig to top or bottom? Heck, he had never done that either, not like that anyway.
Would it be any good? Would Tweek be let down by Craigs lack of confidence or sexual knowledge despite being a renowned slut.
He tossed the pillow and ran his fingers through his hair. Catching a glimpse of himself in the mirror. His face was still flushed and his hair was a mess and the gel was now making his hair just look greasy. How the hell did Tweek find this attractive? Hell how did anyone? He wasn’t unaware he was considered hot by near every girl and heck their boyfriend even admitted it- subjectively of course.
But as he looked in the mirror, he could help but be annoyed at the way he looked. He didn’t feel hot.
He was blessed with his mother’s clear skin but his fathers oily skin. His big blue eyes and thick black hair which just wouldn’t sit right. He supposed maybe Tweek was right. A shower was a good idea. His head was all over the place and physically he felt disgusting.
He grabbed his phone scrolling Instagram looking at everyone else’s photos from the night getting distracted until the sound of his bedroom door startled him. Tweek was tall and slender and his towel was wrapped tightly around his waist just low enough Craig could see his hips and where his stomach
“I um- I think im going to go have a shower too” Craig said clearing his throat trying not to stare at the boy in front of him.
“Oh, cool” Tweek nodded “I will um, be here”
“Cool”
“Cool” Tweek stood watching as Craig left the bedroom as a strange twang of fear filled him. Maybe he had been right. Maybe their friendship was ruined. Things hadn’t ever been this awkward between them and Tweek just wished they could go back to normal.
Craig had barely been able to look at him before hurrying out the room leaving Tweek alone to dry his hair looking in the mirror as his hair Nichole had straightened now bouncing back to their damp curls. He admired his own face for a moment. He had felt pretty when Nichole had dressed him up like a doll but he preferred being himself. Did he like the dress? Sure and the makeup, maybe and would he say no if the girls asked him to do it again, who knows? But that was questions for another day.
He opened Craigs closet finding a baggy t-shirt and basketball shorts to borrow before laying on Craigs bed waiting for him to come back.
He wasn’t sure why as he lay on the bed curiosity peaked inside him as the cracked open bedside drawer caught his eye.
He had been in this room and lay on this bed many times but it wasn’t until now any desire to snoop through Craigs things had ever peaked in him. He slid the drawer open not really expecting to find anything. Tissues, comic books, pictures, a diary? But nothing could have prepared him for what he instead found staring back at him badly tucked away under old comics.
Tweek gasped unsure of what to do. Slam it shut and pretend he had never seen it? Was it an exs? Was it Craigs? Had he ever used it- oh god. Tweek felt butterflies in his stomach as the thought of Craig laying on the very bed, he sat on using the toy on himself filled Tweeks mind. There was lube tucked away beside it and Tweek plucked the courage to take them out to inspect them for himself. Craig was a pretty clean person so it didn’t surprise him at all that everything was sanitised and kept clean. He inspected the toy. It was long but thin and flexible. He felt dirty and wrong just touching it even worse as he didn’t know which fantasy he liked more- the one where Craig used it on him or the one here he used it on Craig.
He hid it along with the lube behind a pillow returning to his snooping looking for anything else of interest. However, Craig being the rather simple person he was, was also rather boring. Tweek seemed to have lucked out on his first find and as he closed Craigs closet the bedroom door opened startling Tweek who stumbled back onto the bed.
“What were you doing?” Craig asked frowning a little. He wasn’t mad- just confused. Tweek never startled like that- not recently anyway- hell, things were weird now weren’t they. Tweek sat on the bed wearing one of his t-shirts and shorts and he didn’t mind him borrowing his clothes, if anything seeing him in them was hotter than anything else he could wear.
“Nothing” Tweek lied.
“Sure” Craig said opening the closet Tweek had just been snooping in as Craig found himself some clothes to change into from his towel.
“Craig” Tweek said “What are you doing?”
“Putting some clothes on” Craig said turning to look at the blonde rather confused
“Why?” Tweek asked a small smirk creeping onto his lips
“Because I would be naked without them” Craig said somehow even more confused.
“Good” Tweek chuckled grabbing Craigs towel ripping it off from around his waist
“Tweek!” Craig gasped
“Don’t be modest now” Tweek said standing backing Craig against his closet door.
“W-What?” Craig felt like he was choking on his own tongue unsure of what to say
“I don’t want things to be weird” Tweek said placing his hands either side of Craigs face “I don’t like it”
“I don’t either-“
“So what are we going to do about it?” Tweek asked but before Craig could reply Tweek pushed his lips into Craigs the fresh clean smell radiated from them both and the clinging smell of the body wash and musky shampoo.
Craig took his turn to take control over the situation pushing Tweek back onto the bed climbing atop him as their lips sucked at each other saliva soaking their bottom lips as they bit at them.
Tweek liked the lack of awkward tension between them but being pressed between the bed and Craig gave him very little control which he didn’t appreciate taking back the power despite physically being less muscular than Craig he was still strong, lugging around kgs of coffee all day from the age of 4 will do that to you.
Flipping them over so Craig was now looking up at the blonde straddling his lap.
“Hey” Tweek mumbled against his lips
“I like this” Craig gulped feeling Tweek breathing just as hard against him.
“Me too… I have to tell you something” Tweek admitted sitting up still sitting on the dark haired boys lap. Craig ran his hands up Tweeks side pulling the t-shirt up off him.
“What is it?” Craig asked as he tossed the t-shirt.
“I… I looked through you things”
“You did!? Why?” Craig asked his eyes blown wide
“I was curious and-“
“Tweek-“
“Sh!” Tweek pressed a finger to Craigs lips to the blue-eyed boys surprise. “I think we both know what I found” He whispered
“I-fuck” Craig cussed out “You don’t think its weird do you?”
“Weird? Dude I think its hot as fuck” Tweek chuckled reaching behind the pillow taking out the long silicone toy.
“Oh god” Craig cringed.
“You use this?” Tweek asked
“S-Sometimes” Craig admitted “Sometimes it the only thing that can get me off”
“Fuck, for some reason I didn’t take you for the sort” Tweek chuckled
“You also didn’t know I was gay” Craig reminded him
“True” Tweek shrugged “Anyway how would you feel if maybe… we used this?”
“On me?” Craig asked feeling his cheeks burn
“Would you like that?”
“Y-Yeah” Craig chocked out nodding as he propped himself up on his elbows as Tweek got off his lap “Can I um- admit something”
“Of course” Tweek smiled in a way that just made Craig melt to his core. He was so pretty and hot and the way his damp curls framed his face just made Craig feel weak.
“I prepared” He cleared his throat anxiously
“Fuck, you slut” Tweek gasped teasingly.
“Be quiet my parents are sleeping” Craig reminded him
“I’ll be the one telling you that soon enough” Tweek was enjoying teasing the blue eyed boy who’s face was pale and cheeks burning pink. He couldn’t help but think about how ironic it was. Their high school star football player who had every boy envious and every girl drooling was laying naked on his bed waiting for him to fuck him with this silicone cock.
Craig lay back resting his head against the pillows as Tweek took the lube squeezing it out into his hand. Craig didn’t have to be asked to open his legs doing so almost instinctively as Tweek climbed onto the bed sitting between his open legs.
“Have you done this before?” Craig asked swallowing the dry lump in his throat.
“Ive seen porn” Was all Tweek said rather not reassuring Craig although he didn’t get time to dwell on it as Tweek was prodding at his hole with his lubed fingers coating the entrance with thick globs of the gel.
“Mhm” Craig hummed as the foreign sensation of having someone else touch him down there radiated through his timid body.
“Breath” Tweek reminded him as without warning penetrating him with a long lubed finger.
“Oh god” Craig gasped closing his eyes trying to just focus on breathing through the feeling.
“How does it feel?” Tweek asked
“Mhm” Craig nodded
“I think that means good” Tweek smirked earning a weak nod back.
“Good boy” Tweek praised him as a second finger was added into Craigs entrance making him gasp which made Tweek’s cock in his- well Craig’s- shorts. There was no doubt that Craig Tucker gasping as he fucked him with his fingers was now possibly the hottest thing he had ever seen.
Tweek trust the 2 fingers slowly listening to the weak mewls slipping from Craigs lips as without warning adding a 3rd making Craig let out a loud moan grabbing the bed sheets. Tweek felt his heart beat quicken admiring the sight in front of him. He looked at the silicone cock sitting beside him wondering when to use it. Should he just ask Craig? Truth be told he was enjoying this teasing and having the control but was more than a little unfamiliar with it and now he had kind of maxed out what he was for sure confident with.
“Are you okay?” Tweek asked, 3 fingers buried to the knuckle inside Craig.
“God yes” Craig gasped
“A-Are you ready?” Tweek asked
“Ready? Oh ready, yes” Craig tried to catch his breath feeling Tweek remove his fingers and the lube cap be removed again. Craig could feel his eyes rolling back into his head every time Tweek touched him. Whatever he was doing he was good at it and surpassed anything Craig had ever fantasised.
“Be slow” Craig said as he felt the tip graze his entrance
“Oh okay” Tweek said as he held the toy teasing Craig a little with it admiring how his hole looked so hungry for the silicone begging for it to be pushed inside.
Slowly Tweek began to insert the toy, just the tip at first and then inch by inch until about the half way point.
“Fuck, fuck” Craig groaned “Stop”
“Are you okay?” Tweek asked panic setting in
“I-I cant take that much” Craig blushed admitting as he closed his eyes biting down on his bottom lip.
“Cant? Or don’t want to?” Tweek asked
“Tweek- Agh” Craig gasped as the toy was edged a little further inside of him.
“How am I supposed to fuck you if you an only take 4 inches?” Tweek teased
“Oh god Tweek” Craig panted as his mouth hung open
“Do you want to keep going?” Tweek asked
“O-Okay” Craig couldn’t even finish his thought before he felt the toy which was penetrating his hole sink further inside of him.
Loud, long mewls and moans were spilling from Craigs mouth without thought as the stretch became painful. His legs shaking and his toes curling as he found himself unable to control the sounds his mouth kept betraying him with.
“Shhh, don’t want to wake up Thomas and Laura” Tweek chuckled “Or maybe we do” As he inserted the final inch of silicone making Craig moan loudly again much to Tweeks pleasure.
“Look, wasn’t so bad was it?” Tweek asked now that the toy was buried fully deep inside of him.
“F-Fuck me” Craig panted as his legs quivered uncontrollably and his mouth was dry unable to swallow the lump forming in his throat.
Tweek didn’t need to be asked twice as he slowly withdrew the toy a little and fucking it back into him.
“Agh” Craig whimpered “Tweek!”
Little by little Tweek withdrew more and more of the long toy fucking the whole length into Craigs stretched gaping hole which was spuing excess lube.
Tweek felt himself begin to groan at the sight as his cock began to ach uncomfortably in the shorts begging to be released and buried deep into Craigs pretty pink hole.
Tweek worked the length until he could fuck the whole 10 inches of the toy from tip to base in and out of Craig. Craig could feel Tweek grazing his prostate but through his uncontrollable moans couldn’t find the words to tell him.
“Mhm there” Craig whimpered
“Here?” Tweek asked thrusting the toy how he think he had just done it.
“Oh god yes Tweek!” Craig almost yelled out “There!”
Tweek didn’t need to be asked twice as now he focused on abusing Craigs prostate watching as he did Craigs leaky cock spew precum onto his stomach.
“Fuck look at you” Tweek gasped as he felt saliva building in his mouth threatening to spill out.
“Mhm yes- Oh Tweek im going to come!” Craig moaned bucking his hips however to his disappointment instead Tweek just removed the toy swiftly leaving Craig both with the loss of his orgasm and the feeling of the toy inside of him.
“Tweek what the f-“ Craig began to protest propping himself up on his elbows before seeing the blonde kick off the shorts. Tweeks throbbing cock between his legs making Craig collapse back onto the bed closing his eyes as he braced himself for what was coming. What he had dreamt of, what had consumed so many of his guilty fantasy’s was now about to come true and all he could do was lay there as he felt Tweek maneuver his legs so they were wide and bent up towards his chest.
He braced himself feeling premature whimpers building on his lips as he waited for Tweek to be ready. He tried to steady his breathing gasping as he felt Tweeks cock head grazing his hole. He had been so wrong. The real thing felt so much better than the toy, he thought they couldn’t be much different but feeling Tweek line his throbbing cock head against him was already driving Craig insane.
He inhaled sharply feeling the intrusion into his body. Tweeks cock was a lot thicker than the toy and he could feel the added stretch the toy hadn’t given him as a chocked moan grew from his throat as he gripped the bed sheets. Tweek wasn’t patient and perhaps just as much as Craig desperate for his orgasm.
“Oh god, you feel so good” Tweek groaned as he hovered above Craig.
“Fuck-“ Was all Craig incoherent mind was able to muster as Tweek thrust his hips trying to find that spot which would make Craig go crazy again. Tweek knew he wasn’t going to last long and he wanted- hell- needed Craig to come before or at the same time as him.
“Oh yes” Craig threw his head back giving Tweek the confirmation he had found it again as his already tiering hips focused on ploughing into the whimpering boy below him helping him reach his climax.
Craig couldn’t string a coherent sentence as his mind was a mush of moans and whines. Tweek looked so pretty above him and the only clear thought his brain could muster was why the hell hadn’t they been doing this for years.
Tweek could feel his hips weakening as he pushed on through his own pain to get Craig to climax. The slapping wet sounds of their bodies mixed with the grunts and moans of the boys to create an unholy amalgamation of lust, sweat and sex filled room.
“I need to cum- please, please” Craig gasped looking up into Tweeks bright eyes.
“Cum for me” Tweek grunted almost as if to give his own body permission to finally orgasm itself. Craig let out a loud moan as Tweek pressed their foreheads together feeling Craigs cock throb as it spurted cum between their bodies.
Tweek rode out of own orgasm bucking his hips weakly as he filled Craig with his own come before collapsing on top of him.
“Oh holy shit” Craig gasped
“That was amazing” Tweek panted as both boys tried to catch their breath.
“We should do that again” Craig kissed the blondes head.
“Yeah but next time I want what you had, it looked good”
“It was” Craig smirked “You’re amazing”
“No you are” Tweek retorted making them both laugh weakly as their tiered bodies lay limp against each other holding one another as their eyes fluttered closed.
“Good morning boys” Thomas greeted them as they sleepily made their way down to breakfast with the rest of the Tucker family.
“Mhm” Craig weakly acknowledged his father as he sat across from him at the table
“Now correct me if im wrong but don’t boys usually bring home girls after prom not their friends” Thomas chuckled
“Its their dates” Trisha said “They take their dates home”
“Same thing, isn’t it?” Thomas shrugged
“Not for Craig” Trisha smirked
“Dude” Craig frowned at her “What the fuck”
“What do you mean?” Thomas asked
“Nothing, Trisha is just being a bitch” Craig kicked his sister under the table
“Craig, language!” His mother reprimanded him from the kitchen
“She started it” Craig muttered under his breath
“Listen to you, almost going to college and you’re starting fights with your little sister like a child” Thomas tutted
“What are you even arguing about?” Laura asked as she brought a plate of waffles from the kitchen to the dining table
“Craig and Tweek are- Ouch!” Trisha yelped
“Dude you are such a snitch” Craig scolded her
“No you snitched on yourself, all I could hear while I was watching my movie was-“
“That’s enough” Craig frowned at her threatening to kick her again before the girl dodged with her legs
“Craig what is she talking about?” Thomas asked
“Craig and I slept together last night” Tweek blurted out
“Tweek what the fuck” Craigs eyes winded “And why did you say it like that, you’re not 40”
“Oh” Thomas and Laura said in shock
“All I could hear was” Trisha replicated the banging by thumping her foot off the floor.
“Well I um… im happy for you boys” Laura said unsure of where to put her eyes.
“Mom don’t be weird about it” Craig sighed
“Im not, im not im just… surprised is all”
“Tweek was your prom date?” Thomas asked confused
“Yup…” Craig said
“Do you have any pictures?” Thomas asked and Tweek and Craig looked at each other wide eyed. Poor Thomas Tucker wasn’t ready for that.